Preserving Access to Web Publications
Wendy Smith, Manager - PANDORA Project, National Library of Australia,
Canberra, ACT 2600, AUSTRALIA. Phone +61 6 262 1622 Fax+61 6 257
1703 wsmith@nla.gov.au
Margaret E Phillips, Manager - Australian Electronic Unit, National
Library of Australia, Canberra, ACT 2600, AUSTRALIA. Phone +61
6 262 1140 Fax+61 6 257 1703 mphillips@nla.gov.au
Debbie Campbell, Research Officer, PANDORA Project, National Library of
Australia, Canberra, ACT 2600, AUSTRALIA. Phone +61 6 262 1673 Fax+61 6
257 1703 dcampbell@nla.gov.au
Keywords
preservation, access, libraries, online publishing, electronic archive
Abstract
The preservation and provision of long term access to online electronic
publishing is generating considerable discussion. The National
Library of Australia's PANDORA project has been set up to develop
policies and procedures for ensuring long term access to significant
Australian materials mounted on the Web.
Introduction
The Web has proved to be a very attractive medium for publishing.
However, the difficulties of finding appropriate information on
the Web and then of ensuring its long term accessibility has created
problems for libraries. Practices that work for books do not always
translate directly to online materials. The preservation and provision
of long term access to electronic publishing is generating considerable
discussion [HREF1]. The National Library of Australia's PANDORA
project has been set up to develop policies and procedures for
ensuring long term access to significant Australian materials
[HREF2] mounted on the Web.
Web publications are not like printed books!
Some things make them better than printed books. This has made
them very attractive to produce and use, and has, in part, accounted
for their exponential rate of growth on the Web. Some things make
web publications worse than printed books - often difficult to
find in the first place then difficult to guarantee their long-term
survival. See the Table that follows for a discussion of some
of these points.
The solution - an 'archive' of Australian online publications
Major Australian research libraries are very concerned that information
be preserved and made accessible to future generations. The transitory
nature of information published on the Web is a cause for concern.
With electronic publishing only a few years old, the time is right
to commence an 'archive' of electronic publications which will
document these historic developments for future generations. The
National Library of Australia has established its PANDORA project
aimed at Preserving and Accessing Networked DOcumentary Resources
of Australia. [HREF3]
The PANDORA archive
The National Library of Australia has established the PANDORA
project to:
- identify and catalogue significant Australian online publications
using established guidelines [HREF4]
- arrange with the owners of these publications to capture a
copy of their publication for safe keeping in the National Library's
electronic archive
- make the information available to users in line with fair
dealing provisions, while taking into account the publisher's
commercial interests
- update the information in the archive on an ongoing and systematic
basis, while maintaining date stamped previous 'editions'.
- migrate information in the archive to new formats as current
technology ages
Some other benefits
There are wider ramifications of the PANDORA project. Associated
developments include:
- contributing to discussions on extending copyright and legal
deposit to online publications;
- implementing a system of permanent naming for Australian publications
to overcome the location problems associated with change of service
provider;
- implementing a system of describing documents based on the Dublin
Core attributes, to make online searching for information more
efficient;
- cooperating with other Australian libraries to ensure that there
is no duplication of archived materials.
Conclusion
Considerable progress has already been made, and we are looking
forward to continuing to cooperate with the owners of online information
to make the PANDORA archive a valuable library resources for Australia.
Table
Some advantages and disadvantages of web publications
| Advantages | Disadvantages
|
- hypertext links enable speedy jumps between different parts of the same publication or even into entirely different publications
- web publications can incorporate multimedia - sound, images, video - almost as easily as plain text
- browsing or keyword searching can (sometimes!) be very effective - material covering a wide range of topics can be found on the Web
- any one can publish on the Web, as long as they have access to an Internet provider (some people might think this was a disadvantage)
- web publishing has immediacy - there need be almost no time delay from preparation of the manuscript till publication
- as a corollary, Web publishing is very current - information is added almost as soon as it happens
- web publications are not housed in any one location - you can browse the Web wherever you have an online computer.
- web publications are available very easily to a very wide audience,
and as Web access expands, the audience continues to grow>.
- it is possible to find a large amount of any topic by searching or by
following links from one publication to another.
- the availability of Web publications has enabled libraries to easily
provide access to the general public, and on a grander scale than is
possible with print based materials.
- web publications are mostly available without charge - at least,
they are at the moment.
|
- there are no standardised ways of finding information about new publications.
- they are not covered by legal deposit legislation - this legislation has ensured that all Australian printed publications are deposited for posterity in at least one major library
- you can't hold them in your hands, and quickly browse their contents - it might take many pages of scrolling, or jumping from URL to URL to find out what the online document is about.
- current online search strategies are not very selective - they can pick up much more information than you really wanted, and do not always closely interpret your request
- they can change their home address without warning - and if you call at their old address they may not have left a forwarding address.
- if the publisher's address changes, hypertext links to the previous site cease to be active - 'link rot' means that parts of the publication can just get lost
- online publications are 'virtual' - they can disappear completely if their owner ceases to maintain his site, or for some other reason they are deleted.
- they are not all enclosed within one set of covers like a book - some Web publications range over a range of sites using hypertext links
- information on any site can be relatively easily changed at any time - the information you found once before might be completely changed in the current online version.
|
Hypertext references
HREF1
http://www.nla.gov.au/policy/paep.html - National Strategy
for Provision of Access to Australian Electronic Publications:
A National Library of Australia Position Paper
HREF2
http://www.nla.gov.au/nla/staffpaper/mphillips3.html - Ensuring
Long Term Access to Online Australian Publications: National Library
of Australia Initiatives
HREF3
http://www.nla.gov.au/policy/plan/pandora.html - Preserving
& Accessing Networked Documentary Resources of Australia (PANDORA)
Project
HREF4
http://www.nla.gov.au/1/scoap/scoapgui.html - Selection Committee
on Online Australian Publications (SCOAP): Guidelines for the
Selection of Online Australian Publications Intended for Preservation
by the National Library
Copyright
National Library of Australia ©, 1997. The authors assign
to Southern Cross University and other educational and non-profit
institutions a non-exclusive licence to use this document for
personal use and in courses of instruction provided that the article
is used in full and this copyright statement is reproduced. The
authors also grant a non-exclusive licence to Southern Cross University
to publish this document in full on the World Wide Web and on
CD-ROM and in printed form with the conference papers, and for
the document to be published on mirrors on the World Wide Web.
Any other usage is prohibited without the express permission of
the authors.
[All Papers and Posters]
AusWeb97
Third Australian World Wide Web Conference, Southern Cross University,
PO Box 157, Lismore NSW 2480, Australia Email:
"AusWeb97@scu.edu.au"